Debate first impressions: No knock out blows; neither candidate outshone the other. Both seemed comfortingly nervous. It's oddly reassuring to know the big guys feel the same pressures we would. You could see Mr. Kerry's hands tremble as he gestured, and the President's voice had that curious upward inflection he gets when he's not sure he's persuading you.

Mr. Bush was more likable and (eventually) relaxed, Mr. Kerry more stern and serious. The President presented the more optimistic, positive ideas, Senator Kerry was more negative and critical.

Ultimately, I think President Bush's message resonated more with the average american: "The best way to protect this country is to stay on the offensive." Mr. Kerry offered a critique, asserted he could do better, but never spelled out a compelling vision of how.

Neither candidate was stellar, but if I had to pick a winner it would have to be Mr. Bush -- not by much -- for a more cogent anti-terrorism strategy and winning personal style.